All roofing contractors in Columbus
Westerville, Ohio / listing

Muth & Company Roofing

Ranked #3 locally in Westerville

Muth & Company Roofing is rated 4.8 out of 5 based on 425 Google reviews in Westerville, Ohio. 7 years in business. Roofing #3 of 3 roofers indexed here.

7 years in business · (614) 882-0900

72/ 100 Reputation Score
Score breakdown

Why this score?

Customer rating41.3 / 43 points
Review volume22.8 / 36 points
Years in business7.4 / 21 points
Total71.5 / 100
Evidence review

What we checked

Confirmed signals from Google, business records, and the applicable licensing source.

Business History7 yearsyears in business
License StatusNo matching recordNo license record matched in our search of Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board. This does not mean the contractor is unlicensed — confirm directly before hiring.
Rating breakdown

The aggregate signal.

4.8 / 5425 reviews on Google
Read all 425 reviews on Google →
Business hours

When they’re open.

Monday8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Tuesday8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Wednesday8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Thursday8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
Friday8:00 AM – 5:00 PM
SaturdayClosed
SundayClosed
License record

No matching record found.

Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board

No license record matched in our search of Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board. This does not mean the contractor is unlicensed — confirm directly before hiring.

Coverage trail

Carriers this contractor lists.

Liberty MutualUSAAAllstate

Confirm active coverage and limits directly before work begins.

Your experience

Add firsthand context.

Leave an original ReputationTiger review based on your own experience with this contractor.

Before you hire

Questions about Muth & Company Roofing.

Is Muth & Company licensed in Ohio?

No license record matched in our search of Ohio Construction Industry Licensing Board. This does not mean the contractor is unlicensed — confirm directly before hiring. ReputationTiger does not treat a missing match as proof that Muth & Company Roofing is unlicensed. Ask for current registration details, confirm the record directly with the applicable board, and make sure the legal business name and project scope match before signing a contract.

How many Google reviews does Muth & Company have?

This profile records a 4.8-star Google rating from 425 reviews. That aggregate is a useful reputation signal, but it is not a complete account of every project or a substitute for checking recent references, contract terms, insurance, and licensing requirements before hiring.

What services does Muth & Company offer?

Muth & Company Roofing lists roof-repair, roof-replacement, roof-inspection, storm-damage-repair, gutters as services. This is a profile description, not a guarantee that every crew or project includes each service. Confirm the exact scope, materials, exclusions, permits, cleanup, and warranty terms in a written estimate before authorizing work.

How long has Muth & Company been in business?

Muth & Company Roofing is listed as having 7 years in business. Business age is one context signal, not a guarantee of current performance or project quality. Confirm the current legal entity, recent references, insurance, written scope, payment schedule, and warranty terms before hiring.

Does Muth & Company list insurance coverage?

Muth & Company Roofing lists Liberty Mutual, USAA, Allstate in this profile. ReputationTiger has not independently verified active coverage, policy limits, or whether the carrier information applies to your project. Request a current certificate of insurance directly and confirm coverage with the carrier before work starts.

Head-to-head

Nearest-ranked contractors.

ContractorScoreRatingReviewsYears
Muth & Company RoofingCurrent profile724.84257
Storm Guard Roofing of Columbus704.94398
Lifetime Quality Roofing704.76429

Compared with the nearest-ranked indexed contractors in the same city and service category.

Storm Guard Roofing of Columbus leads Muth & Company on the higher rating (4.9 vs 4.8), while Muth & Company remains the current profile at a 2-point Reputation Score gap; the trade-off is the competitor's stronger measured signal versus keeping this profile in the comparison for written scope, price, and warranty.

Are you the owner?

Claim Muth & Company Roofing.